“I have an open, tolerant and plural position [in relation to bullfighting], but that is not reflected in fiscal policy options”, said Pedro Adão e Silva in parliament.
In response to the interventions of Chega and PAN, two parties with totally opposite positions in relation to bullfighting, Pedro Adão e Silva said that the Government does not intend to lower the 23% VAT applied to bullfighting, but that it should not intervene in this practice either.
“I am very much in line with the Portuguese in common sense, wisdom and balance. […] Don't count on me to censor the cultural practices and tastes of others and make definitive judgments”, said Pedro Adão e Silva.
The minister stated that he is not a bullfighting fan, but said that one should “respect the way others look at Culture”.
The minister thus underlined a position he called “tolerance” towards bullfighting, in contrast to his predecessor, Graça Fonseca, who went so far as to say that it was “a matter of civilization”.
For Pedro Adão e Silva, there is space for the representation of the political positions of PAN and Chega “and in the middle there are the Portuguese”, who do not go to bullfights, but do not want to prevent others from going.
“It doesn't cross our minds to stop the Portuguese. The state does not support bullfighting in any way, and it is not a matter the state should meddle in,” he underlined.
I completely agree with Sr. Silva, a well balanced judgement. I am a north European and I don't like bullfighting (even though the Portuguese don't actually kill bulls). It is wrong to impose on people's culture, in Europe we are all different, and I respect the right of Iberian folk to engage in this. If we are to see the end of bullfighting in these two countries, then it is for the indigenous people to decide they no longer support it. I feel anxious that the EU Commission (in the north) sometimes impose regulations that do not take proper account of national traditions. Let the Iberians decide when it is time to stop. I am sure it will die out eventually.
By Christopher Hart from Algarve on 12 May 2022, 20:29
If bullfighting were done with bulls in full good form and the bullfighter on foot w/pink towel but w/out those spike things they torture the bull w/…i´d watch that, bc it would actually take SKILL to avoid the bull´s horns, i´d root for the animal. As it is, it´s for COWARD SISSIES, who like to take their personal frustrations on an innocent animal.
By guida from Lisbon on 13 May 2022, 05:35
Torture is not culture.
It's not allowed to humans and should not be allowed to people.
If you want to remember barbaric traditions of the past, fake it.
Humans should evolve and respect other living beings. At this time they dont even respect each other!
By Jon Collier from Lisbon on 13 May 2022, 10:49
Respect for a culture that causes untold suffering and pain - that is beyond unacceptable! In the 21st century, when we understand that animals are sentient and display love and compassion, we should be thoroughly ashamed of ourselves when we ignore this cruelty and it should be stopped. There are many other "cultures" that have fallen by the wayside because we've become aware that they are evil. "Common sense" ?? what a joke! There is absolutely no sense in any form that can justify what is done to the animals that are forced to fight without hope, for their lives. "It takes nothing from a human to be kind to an animal" - "the worth of a nation is reflected in how it treats it's animals". It's absolutely heartbreaking..... shame on anyone who enjoys this "sport".
By Jenny Keating from Algarve on 13 May 2022, 12:02
Tradition is an explanation for acting without thinking. Grace McGarvie
By BeetzMe from Algarve on 13 May 2022, 13:22
Slavery was one a Portuguese "tradition". Fortunately times and barbaric practices can change. No point criticizing whale hunting while you are torturing animals at home.
By Joana from Lisbon on 13 May 2022, 19:50