There was a crisp knock-knock on our apartment door the other day and since our old building’s intercom has been broken for some time, we don’t have the benefit of communicating with people from the lobby intercom system nor buzzing them up. So who is coming up to the 4th floor to get our attention?
When I opened our apartment door there was our bubbling mailman, Nuno, with a big smile and an official letter in hand. “Looks like you’ll be staying!” he exclaimed, holding an envelope and noting that the letter was from IMT, Portugal’s department of motor vehicles. We barely know the man, having interacted with him on a couple of other occasions and learned his name. But this was a moment to celebrate, after more than 6 months, Ron got his Portugal driver’s license!
In America that exchange with the postman we barely know might have been a little creepy. But in Portugal, it’s yet another precious and rich interaction with a citizen of the country we now call home.
Not a day goes by that Ron and I don’t exchange knowing glances – often verbalizing, “Aren’t these people lovely?!”. Usually the interaction has us on the receiving end of a kindness extended and a generosity of spirit – that transcends any transaction.
Relationships, Social Connections and Community
If you’ve visited or now live in Portugal, chances are you know what I’m talking about. Oh yes, there can be those moments where we bump up against an unhappy person with a brusque attitude. But those times are minuscule in comparison to the open-arms reception we usually receive among the Portuguese.
There are countless Facebook pages that focus on the experiences of American expats/immigrants living or making the transition to live in Portugal. And in the chat threads Americans frequently recount heartfelt interactions with Portuguese. I remember one person, an American expat, reporting their experience of waiting in line to check-out at the grocery store. The elderly man in front of them was chatting with the cashier well beyond the time it took for him to bag and pay. Once he did shuffle off, the cashier turned her attention to the person reporting the experience and apologized for the extra time it took, saying the senior citizen was recently widowed and alone and needed a little friendly conversation. The commenter was touched by the thoughtfulness in this outreach. Others in the thread wholeheartedly agreed. The subtext of such experiences is that they’re in stark contrast to the “keep it moving” hustle and bustle of American culture.
A Great Big Hug versus Rugged Individualism
While it's challenging to definitively compare the relationship-based infrastructure of Portugal to the United States, there are certain factors that may contribute to the perception of Portugal having a more warm and fuzzy feel.
For example, Portugal, like many Mediterranean countries (and Portugal is considered a Mediterranean country), has a long history of close-knit communities and social connections. Traditional Portuguese culture places a strong emphasis on interpersonal relationships and extended family ties.
Of course, Americans can be friendly and welcoming, but digging into sociological roots, there’s a greater emphasis on personal space and independence among Americans. Individualism is considered a strong value in American society. (Remember the term “rugged individualism” applied to the American frontier experience – relying on self-sufficiency to survive?)
The size of the two countries is also theorized to contribute to the difference in social cohesion and connection. Portugal has more than 10 million people living in a compact area about the size of the state of Indiana. The U.S. on the other hand, has about 330 million people spread over a vast space (107 times bigger than Portugal) resulting in a more diverse and geographically far-flung society.
Given this, America’s sheer size and uneven population density can make it challenging to maintain a tightly knitted relationship-based infrastructure. In addition, the U.S. with its long history of suburban sprawl and car-centric infrastructure, begets more individualistic and less relationship-oriented communities. Itty-bitty Portugal, so it goes, with its higher population density lends itself to nurturing closer social connections and more localized relationships.
Of course, these kind of generalizations about entire populations can be misleading because peoples’ behaviors and attitudes vary greatly within any country. However, if you have had personal experiences that have shaped your perspectives about this, I (and a whole bunch of other readers) would love to hear them. I invite you to share your thoughts in the comments section or connect with me via email.
Becca Williams is settling into small town living in Lagos, a seaside town on Portugal’s southern coast. Contact her at AlgarveBecca@gmail.com
Becca Williams lives in Lagos, a seaside town on Portugal’s southern coast. Contact her at AlgarveBecca@gmail.com.
An exchange with the postman is considered creepy in America......??!!
Perhaps only in America.
By Annie from Algarve on 09 Jul 2023, 20:03
Annie, I often find responses like yours so puzzling. This seemingly lovely woman wrote something that reads as an appreciative "love letter" to the kindness of the Portuguese, an all you took from it was a throwaway sentence you felt the need to comment upon? And then completely missing the larger point of the opinion piece? Sadly, there is a decay within American society, that for better or worse, is driving the more rational, loving and sane people to find like minded souls in other places in the world that make them feel like they belong and can offer that same support in return. Condescendingly commenting on something you cherry-picked from a larger overview of the happiness someone feels at feeling safe and belonging is a bit cruel. Please don't portray your fellow citizens in such a bad light. It is unbecoming and unwelcoming.
By Brian from Porto on 10 Jul 2023, 02:24
Another article from this self-obsessed American desperate for an opportunity for self promotion.
By Billy Bissett from Porto on 10 Jul 2023, 10:10
Well, Brian, Mrs Becca didn't have to make such a badly chosen statement to highlight differences in social connections between two countries of contrasting demographics and cultures, while most of her piece addressed the topic in general terms anyway.
By Annie from Algarve on 10 Jul 2023, 11:41
This lovely american woman seems to have a huge need for recognition.
I'm surprised that Portugal News always prints her outpourings.
By Nick from Lisbon on 10 Jul 2023, 13:14
My husband and I have a shorthand phrase we often use when one of us is telling the other about some interaction or other that took place: we refer to a person as "a typical Portuguese", which is understood to mean "a warm, openhearted and lovely person".
By Deborah from Lisbon on 10 Jul 2023, 15:18
As a Brit I too find the Portuguese lovely. our neighbours give us vegetables, everyone waves when you drive through the village, in the small town nearby shopkepers are friendly. and standard greeting ,even if meeting for the first time is a 2cheek kiss.
By jo eliot from UK on 10 Jul 2023, 17:15
The author of the article says that Portugal is a Mediterranean nation. Nothing could be further from the truth. Portugal’s people, their history and tbeir culture have always looked to the Atlantic. Portugal is an Atlantic nation not Mediterranean.
By Herbert Silva from USA on 10 Jul 2023, 19:01
I thoroughly enjoy reading Beccas' interactions and experiences with the Portuguese people. Everything she expresses is true about the Portuguese friendly spirit.
By Lisa from Other on 11 Jul 2023, 00:27
Having watched an episode or two of 'Judge Judy' and see the amount of coverage that the deranged ex-president receives in the American press, I am not surprised that Americans are leaving their fractured country.
By Greg from Other on 11 Jul 2023, 12:36
Living in Lagos and extrapolating her experiences there to Portugal as a whole is a step too far. The Algarve economy is dependant on tourism and wealthy expats. Not surprising that the 'locals' will welcome you with open arms, you're their breadwinner. Not surprising that the postman was glad another expat was staying! The situation is very different elsewhere with foreigners being treated with a mixture of friendliness, unfriendliness and indifference in varying proportions as one would expect in pretty much any country, Portugal is no exception.
I entirely agree with Billy Bisset and Nick.
By David from Beiras on 11 Jul 2023, 12:44
Well, Becca writes what the majority Americans and Portuguese want to read.
By Tom from Lisbon on 11 Jul 2023, 16:58
Portugal has it's roots on the cruzaders that went out to free Jerusalem from the moslems, and has been a Christian country for centuries. Portugal as a Christian country must show the love of Christ, because God is Love, so you should love one another.
By Tony from Other on 11 Jul 2023, 18:00
I am just embarrassed by the disgusting comments here attacking this woman personally. But worse, so much of it is anti-American, nationalistic hate. So many comments mention "American", denigrating her and her country of origin.
Worse, most seem to be from immigrants to Portugal or those wishing to move, as they are not native Portuguese names.
A woman writes something polite, interesting, etc, and people write horrible things about her and her country? Is this the way you want the people from your home nation to appear, while writing about someone for doing something so innocuous? Who is worse here? Who has the moral high ground? The woman simply telling her story, or the people attacking her for doing so?
Honestly, The Portugal News should not tolerate these kind of stupid, immature and ignorant comments. They should be deleted. And I will remind all of the anti-American commenters, especially those from the UK, based on names and the language used: if it weren't for Americans, who lost more people in the two World Wars than the GB did, fighting in Europe to keep Europe free of tyranny, you'd be writing in German on this website.
How short your memories are for recent WW's, while apparently still being mad about America and the Revolutionary War.
Aja como adultos e dê um tempo,
Ricardo
By Ricardo Silveira from Lisbon on 12 Jul 2023, 20:41
Great piece, good to note that expecting everyone to stereotypically be accommodating and friendly, would be an error.
There is a notable difference in sociability and friendliness among the Portuguese; with familial ties having priority. I want to encourage immigrants to mirror the kindness and create an exchange, rather than just being a mere recipient maintaining stiff American norms.
I want to add that, as in many countries struggling with poverty, perceptions of Americans having plenty of money, does on occasion play into the over-friendliness, and super-accommodating behaviors of a few… so also be wise.
By Cynthia Santiago from Lisbon on 13 Jul 2023, 08:28
Holy Moly! This thread reminds me of the Biblical story of the Tower of Babel. The original post is what it is: word salad dressed with Splenda, but the culinary reviews range from Michelin four-star to failed fast-food fodder. One man/woman/other’s* trash is another’s treasure.
By Dante from Beiras on 16 Jul 2023, 07:35
My take on Becca's article is that it's often the little things that matter. I too have experienced many random acts of kindness here in Portugal (from strangers, as well as neighbors) here in Lisbon. It costs nothing to be civil & friendly. However, we have been lucky wherever we have lived, in this respect. Maybe we have also chosen well, regarding areas which exude a sense of community. It would seem as though Becca was reflecting & sharing her own positive experience in Portugal. An experience many of us share, & also value. I am therefore puzzled by the abundance of negative remarks...
By David Ninnis from Lisbon on 16 Jul 2023, 14:09