According to The Guardian, the Portuguese man, who arrived in England in May 2001, is a plumber, has no criminal record and has always paid his taxes.
Domenic Tomeo, 48, owner of the company he has worked for since 2007, described João as "a hard worker, 100% reliable". "He's like family to me", he assured.
João said emotionally that he is "afraid" that the British Home Office will send him "back to Portugal". "My parents are dead, I have no one there. The UK is my home and my boss is my family," he explained.
João tried to legalise himself several times but without success
According to The Guardian, it all started in 2019, when João tried to apply for the EUSS (European Union Settlement Scheme), the immigration regime in force for European Union (EU) citizens since Brexit.
He tried to apply both through the Home Office app and the online portal but without success. When he called the helpline, the person who answered him did not understand him "due to a speech impediment and the fact that English is not his first language".
João then decided to turn to an organisation to help him complete his candidacy and he finally managed to do so in November last year, but it was already past the deadline.
Despite this, having justified his delay and his speech difficulties, the Government rejected his candidacy, considering that there were no "reasonable reasons for the delay in presenting" his application and is now threatening to deport him.
In a letter he received from the British Home Office, there are 11 points describing what could happen to him in the near future, including having to pay a fine and being detained or expelled from the United Kingdom.
João's lawyer, Naga Kandiah, recalled that his client has paid his taxes for more than two decades and that he has no record, warning of the risk of the United Kingdom facing yet another scandal similar to the Windrush case, when, in 2018, 83 people were wrongly deported from the country.
Despite the rejection of João's candidacy and not having the right to legal recourse, Naga Kandiah, as well as several civil rights organisations, are exerting pressure to stop the deportation.
The lawyer even filed a lawsuit on the grounds that the rejection of his client's candidacy "violates the EU withdrawal agreement and incorrectly applies" its guidelines, demanding that the United Kingdom accept João's request, as well as grant the right of appeal to similar cases.
Human Rights defenders guarantee that João's case is living proof of the UK government's growing hostility towards EU citizens.
You have to feel sorry for this guy, it’s typical of Govs today, spend time and money on this guy where he is clearly a good person but if you arrive illegally on a rubber boat with no documents you get free accommodation, free food, cash handouts and given a red carpet to stay. What an upside down world this is.
By JG from Algarve on 06 Feb 2024, 06:25
Well that is happening to a lot EU residents and many without any reason despite living their for many years a have jobs and be integrated and contribute for the country in the community are treated like criminals and ask to leave the country . And the other emigrants that that are from Asian countries like India, Pakistan or even other different countries that dont make a single effort to learn the language and like in ghettos and try to impose their believes and costumes in the country they arrive are allowed to stay ? They is something wrong going in the UK completely indeed
By Isabel Oliveira from Lisbon on 06 Feb 2024, 07:16
Whilst feeling very sorry for this gentleman I recall the treatment of Brits from Spain and Portugal ever since Brexit !! There are many reasons for this but sheer spitefulness has been present in good measure. The brush works both ways I’m afraid !!
By Chris Loynes from Algarve on 06 Feb 2024, 14:39
Isabel Oliveira - What a racist comment! If your English was more proficient than those from "Asian countries", you would have understood that the man had "a speech impediment", so yeah, for 20 years he didn't bother to make a single effort to learn English as well.
By JC from Lisbon on 06 Feb 2024, 18:04
They can not do that
Refer to the TREATY OF WINDSOR, (1386) STILL IN FORCE
And never broken
By Bill Hennderson from Algarve on 06 Feb 2024, 19:01
This man's case is NOT evidence of the UK government's hostility to foreigners or immigrants, but a case of mal-administration where due process might not have been followed and this man was denied permission to stay. It looks like a case of incompetence and negligence, but not intentional.
By Billy Bissett from Porto on 06 Feb 2024, 22:52
This case to the majority of people will make little sense, and offend many .
This does sum up the " hostile environment" this conservative government has both practiced and talks. For many of us British nationals we find this unacceptable, an embarrassment, and deeply offensive.
I hope after the next election (soon) many of those concerned find themselves no longer in government, and no longer a member of parliament.
These people represent the worst of British, it appears the majority of the best of British in the UK feel that also, as polls indicate.
We can as UK nationals vote in the coming election, lets make our voice known.
To the Portuguese people (who some are my friends), understand please, this current government does not represent the majority of UK people. As with any nation we have our lunatic idiots. I say sorry to the Portuguese people!
By Ian Dowdle from Alentejo on 07 Feb 2024, 14:47
I know personally this story and there's a lot not being said to the press, like Mr da Silva not actually applying when he should have. We can very well remember what he used to say about the whole thing. " I'm not applying for anything, they know well enough who I am, I've been here 20 years". Mr da Silva's world in Portuguese.
By Rui Santos from UK on 22 Feb 2024, 06:39